Key Readings and Common Ground on ‘Religion’ in Two Senses – Brad Jersak
"Master, grant that I may not so much seek … to be understood as to understand."
– Prayer of St Francis of Assisi –
Following up on my last post, 'Religion in Two Senses,' I felt it would be helpful to offer a sample of good articles written supporting or condemning 'religion' in the two senses I outlined. Then I hope to name three points of critical common ground that will enable us to see the authors' unified concern and agenda.
'Religion' Condemned
To review, the type of 'religion' that some authors condemn is the Christless religion marked by words like religiosity, self-righteousness, spiritual abuse, control and hypocrisy — the dead religion devoid of grace, compassion and mercy — the religious malpractice to which Christ issued repeated 'woes' in Matthew 23. This is the 'religion' that subverts and displaces the revelation of Christ by attempting to achieve or maintain in the flesh (Gal. 3) what Christ alone authors and perfects (Heb. 12, Eph. 2).
'Religion' Affirmed
On the other hand, the type of 'religion' that the authors affirm is the pure and undefile religion of James' Epistle or the worship in Spirit and in Truth of John 4. This 'religion' is identified by the prophets and apostles as centered on Christ–the faith once delivered (Jude) or the gospel we received (1 Cor 15). I personally prefer to call this 'living faith,' but when described as 'religion,' it also carries the sense of Christ-ordained faith practices (baptism, Eucharist, obedience to Christ, etc.) and community (i.e. gathering, beginning with 'two or three are gathered in his name'). It is the religion of self-giving love, peacemaking and forgiveness we read about in Micah, Amos and the Sermon on the Mount.
In this latter sense, Brian Zahnd clarifies his position to highlight how Christianity is 'delivered' and 'received' in that biblical sense:
There is a sense in which it's true that "Jesus didn't come to start a religion." But it's equally true that the coming of Jesus would inevitably result in a religion (or religions!). Religion is how we pass on the faith from generation to generation. Without religion everyone has to start from zero and make their own discoveries. And very few are capable of this. We might think of science as the "religion" of passing on scientific knowledge from one generation to another. If we require each generation to make their own scientific discoveries in the name of "authenticity," this isn't going to make the world more authentic, it will just make the world a whole lot more stupid! To say, "I'm against religion" is pretty close to saying, "I don't care if my grandchildren are Christian or not." I tell people if you have a relationship with Jesus, you can thank the Christian religion for making this possible.
I agree with Brian as I understand him here, and yet I can promise you: Brian is against 'religion' in the first sense–it's just not the word he uses for it (usually). I can make that promise cecause I know that he is against religiosity, self-righteousness, spiritual abuse, control and hypocrisy. Indeed, he has paid the heavy price of publicly echoing Jesus' woes against the other "religious echoes" of the politicized culture wars and their Christless "civil religion." He squares off against these powers week after week. And on the flip side, he is a persistent voice for the 'pure religion' described and affirmed above. To hear him unpack James' use of the term, you can find the podcast entitled "I'm not just spiritual; I'm religious" by clicking HERE (it's #27).
So again, in the interest of hearing each other, I distinguish the uses of 'religion' according to the adjectives modifying it, the questions being addressed and the author's intention in context. To see the two uses in action, here are a few samples from either direction.
read more…
No Results Found
The page you requested could not be found. Try refining your search, or use the navigation above to locate the post.
