Not whether, but how. 

Wai Young
MP Wai Young

 Our British Columbia media recently jumped all over the situation of a sitting MP speaking in her Vancouver Church. From the pulpit she proclaimed that her party’s creation of bill C-51 on fighting the specter of terrorist activity in Canada reflected the courage and will of Jesus (Scott Brown. MP Compares government to Jesus in comments on anti-terrorism bill, Vancouver Sun, July 15, 2015, A 5). She had to sheepishly recant factual errors later, however, and there was considerable debate about the legal appropriateness for her exhort as she did as a sitting MP as well as questioning role of the church as a charitable organization to host the partisan speech. The situation does reflect the fact that both churches and MPs often have religiously-political shaped opinions, either explicitly or implicitly.  Absolute subjective neutrality is humanly impossible, but as a public servant, an MP should know better than to be openly religiously partisan, especially regarding a specific bill; professional discipline as public servant is necessary, unless of course she, or he, is simply interested only in votes, knowing that both the spoken religious convictions and the partisan political references resonate with the audience. The wider public might not be so impressed with the specific partisan identification of party courage with the “courage of Jesus”; a bit self-righteous or grandiose in my opinion.

But should not the Church be a passionate voice in its political interests and perspectives with its belief in Jesus Lordship over all of life? Does the separation of church and state doctrine mandate our being atheists or a-religious in the full spectrum of our public lives? The fundamental issue in my opinion is not whether the church should have a voice in the political arena, but rather just how it actually expresses its voice publically: passive aggressively; anti-intellectually moralistic; or, prudently wise and respectfully prophetic?

Katharine_hayhoe_06ars
Dr. Katharine Hayhoe

In a The Vancouver Sun issue a few months ago, Katharine Hayhoe, Canadian born climate scientist and professor of political science in Texas, speaks of the high incidence of human caused climate change denial in the American Evangelical church. Hayhoe, suggests that, in the US where she works at present, political partisanship has taken over the church, and that especially in the evangelical church, it is actually political ideology that guides the faith, rather than faith guiding politics (William Marsden, A believer among skeptics, The Vancouver Sun, April 25, 2015, p. B 5). Hayhoe implies that when evangelicals generally think and act politically about climate change they do so according to the political ideology and policies of the political party they support, generally the Republican Party.  Also implied, however, is that that political party’s platform is parochial on this issue, nuanced and manipulated by specific evangelical beliefs. There is a kind of reciprocal, double-hermeneutic, at work here of faith being shaped by party ideology, and ideology shaped by the religious doctrines of the party’s supporters. Douglas Todd acknowledges that Canadian evangelical perspectives on climate change have a partisan basis was as well.  He also implies that Harper’s reluctance to get serious about climate change action is influenced by his evangelical beliefs. In general in the evangelical mind, human causes are either impossible, or of no consequence because of the belief in hard determinism, God absolutely controls everything; and believers will be raptured from the sorry consequences of global destruction anyway (Douglas Todd, Evangelicals get real about climate change. Vancouver Sun, May 9, 2015, F 5).

read more…