Is Sacramentalism the Answer to Secularism? – D.L. Jones
There is a growing chorus of scholars across the ecumenical boundaries (Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, and Protestant) that are making the argument that sacramentalism, a sacramental worldview which recognizes the centrality of the liturgy, as the antidote that counteracts the effects of the poison or disease of secularism. Several ecumenical great minds, thinkers, and writers are making this argument in a variety of different ways who include at least the following intellectual cadre: Brad S. Gregory (Roman Catholic), David Bentley Hart (Eastern Orthodox), Hans Boersma (Protestant), and James K.A. Smith (Protestant).
A lot of good historical as well as philosophical and theological points feed into their argument that sacramentalism is the answer to secularism. Nominalism which is a reduction of reality, a flattening of categories, is no doubt one of the root causes of our secular Western viewpoint. Therefore it makes sense that a recognition of the sacred would seem to get at the root of this disease. I understand this point and largely agree with it. Allow me though to ask some questions and bring an important perspective into this dialog that desperately needs to be considered and judged by these men as well as by others good thinkers and folks who are intrigued by this conversation.
I find far too much sentimentality and naivety without critical judgment in their argument that sacramentalism is the answer to secularism. As a person who has lived in both the Catholic and Orthodox world over the last 20 years allow me to inject some reality. Please do not misunderstand my own position though, I agree with them as you will see below but some important arguments, nuances and considerations need to be made to get at this complex problem of how sacramentalism relates to and interacts with secularism.
No Results Found
The page you requested could not be found. Try refining your search, or use the navigation above to locate the post.
