Billboard

A large, ominous, mysterious, billboard along Highway #1 approaching Vancouver from the East boldly proclaims: “Every unjust sentence bullies the victim.”  One wonders what they, whoever “they” are, consider a just sentence, one that bullies back the one committing the harm?  One also wonders on what evidence or grounds they base their theory of justice. The sentiment Implied is that sentences currently given are a pain to the victims; sentences are not severe or painful enough for the offenders. Assumed also is that just sentences can simply be measured in a quantitative sense to reflect in the application of “justice” the same amount of pain (or more)  delivered, as suffered by the victim. Perhaps they desire “throwing the book” at the wrongdoer, meaning sentencing the maximum amount of time sanctioned by the criminal code without any reductions by the Judge. Will the supporters of this legal opinion posted at the Highway, perhaps be satisfied with the recent sentencing of Justin Bourque to seventy-five years for the murders of three policemen and of wounding two others in Moncton in June 2014? Justin was sentenced last Oct 27 (2014) to five concurrent life sentences; he will be prison without eligibility of parole for seventy five years! This sentencing was the harshest sentence given since the abolition of the death penalty in Canada in1975. Is this the kind of justice desired by those behind the opinion written on the sign?

The timing of Justin’s sentencing however, a week after the violence and highly publicized murders of unarmed soldiers in Ottawa and St.-Jean-sur-Richelieu last October (2014), also leads one to wonder at the intent of the public message sent. The tragic events at Ottawa’s National War Memorial and in Quebec are disturbing, and we are all led to expressions of outrage and lament. Raw lament, grief, and confusion, must not, however, be exploited for political ends. These senseless murders of soldiers defy simple quick simply legal answers; so do the murders and violence that Justin Bourque committed. It could be said that, freed by new legislation allowing this kind of concurrent sentence, the judge not only threw the allowable book at Justin, he reflected the nature of the crime: an approximation of life for a life. Even the 18th century Utilitarian crafters of deterrence theory actually considered life sentences even more severe and evil that the death penalty.

read more…