The Challenge of Mary – Katherine Murray
She did not cry, ‘I cannot. I am not worthy,’
Nor, ‘I have not the strength.’
She did not submit with gritted teeth,
raging, coerced.
Bravest of all humans,
consent illumined her.
-Excerpt from Poem: Denise Levertov’s “Annunciation”
It is the second week of Advent, and my attention is turned to Mary and, more specifically, Mary’s fiat, “Be it done onto me according to Your will.” Mary's response to the angel Gabriel’s message that God has chosen her to birth God’s own son is to surrender with a clear ‘yes.' She self-empties her own will – kenosis – so that God’s will can be done. Kenosis is a Greek term meaning “self-emptying,” used by the apostle Paul in Philippians 2:6-11 to help us understand the life of Jesus, Mary’s son. Mary’s “consent to open her sealed body to the presence of the infinite” is her kenotic act.[1] And her choice has cosmic significance.[2]
For half of my life, I was in a protestant, fundamentalist Christian tradition that acknowledged Mary only once a year, at Christmastime, as Jesus’s mother, when we would read the Luke nativity story. That is all I really understood about Mary. But in the last decade and a half, I became more intentional to explore the wider Christian tradition and I also became more deeply contemplative in my spirituality. Curiously, both these movements brought me closer to Mary, who has come to inspire me and teach me, but mostly, challenge me.
Luke writes that Mary pondered the words of the angel (1:29). I ponder Mary’s kenotic choice. Mary has agency and so is free to decline to be impregnated by the Spirit with Jesus. But, incredibly, she renounces her own will and power[3] to be the mother of God-in-flesh. The emptying of her will results in her being filled with God. Through Mary, it is shown that “barrenness is the condition of fruitfulness.”[4] The fruitfulness of Mary’s fiat is that she participates in God becoming flesh – “for in the union of God and humanity, it is Mary who imparts the humanity.”[5] Her consent opens up a way for the beginning of a new creation[6] and “preserves the mystery of life, the power opposed to death.”[7] Mary participates in the redemptive mission of God.[8] She “becomes a sign of grace, the sign of what is truly salvific and healing: the ready openness that submits itself to God’s will.”[9] I stand amazed.
Mary’s kenotic act offers me a window through which to see and understand part of the mystery of God. It is imitative of her own son Jesus before he has even revealed it to the world.[10] Jesus, through both his teaching and how he lived his life, would reveal kenosis as God’s way of being. He would teach in the Sermon on the Mount that, ‘Blessed are the poor in Spirit for theirs is the kingdom of heaven’ (Matthew 5:3). Rather than be full of ourselves, we are to be emptied of egotism, void of willfulness to experience God’s reign.[11] Jesus taught that true power and greatness is not in dominating and oppressing others but by serving all (Matthew 20:25-26). He revealed that “equality with God is not through getting but through giving until he was empty.”[12]
Jesus lived his life doing only what he saw his Father God doing, saying only what he heard his Father God speak (John 5:19, 12:49). He gave himself so completely to this way of being that he consented to suffering and being killed when, in the garden of Gethsemane, he surrendered to God’s will being done and not his own (Luke 22:42). Kenosis is the framework that unifies the entire life of Christ.[13]
In that framework, Jesus revealed that God’s will is done on the earth through the surrender of human will. Kenosis is a revelation of God’s nature.[14] It is in this way that Mary participates in revealing part of the divine mystery.
If we widen the lens on kenosis in scripture, we also see God self-emptying at creation. That is, in creating humanity with the freedom to choose, God made space for humans to choose God’s will or reject it.[15] It is the “lamb slain at the foundation of the world” (Revelation 13:8).[16] Kenosis is present at creation. This is what gives Mary her agency.
We see in God at creation, in Mary’s consent to God, and in Jesus’s full life, that the divine way of reigning is through self-emptying and self-giving.[17] God’s victory is through humility.[18]
From what we read about Mary in the gospels, she does not renounce her fiat. Mary continues to surrender to God’s will being done even when Joseph is about to divorce her, when she has to flee to Egypt to protect Jesus from a genocidal king, and when she fears Jesus lost though he is teaching in the temple. Mary continues in this way as she watches her son live out a unique destiny that sees him misunderstood, rejected, betrayed, tortured, and condemned as a blasphemer and put to death.[19] She continues to self-empty, to live a life of ongoing surrender to God, and in this way, too, is like her son.
In Mary and in Jesus, we see that God has chosen human partners who can bridge heaven and earth. That is, when we renounce our human will so that God’s will is done, it opens up a way for God’s love and presence to be manifested in the world.[20] Sarah Jane Boss describes it this way, “It is because one woman (Mary) did this thing once, decisively, that…Christians have confidence that human beings can mediate the divine presence to the rest of creation.”[21]
Mary opens up a unique window into the divine mystery, helps us see God more clearly, and to understand how God is at work in the world. Francesca Murphy, writing on the Mariology of Hans Urs von Balthasar, captures it this way, “What it means to be Christian in relation to God is articulated in Mary.”[22] In Mary I see that when we renounce our will to do God’s will we are imaging God, we are being like God – for this is God’s nature as revealed at creation and in Jesus.[23] This is no doormat posture! We renounce our own self-will and the power we have to make room for the all-powerful. It is for me a humbling truth.
When I consider the landscape of the world at present and observe horror in the Middle East, rising hate, racism, and violence, a movement to autocratic government and militarism, climate crises, economic hardship, and relationships in need of reconciliation – I ache for God’s loving will to be done upon the earth. When I consider Mary’s life, I see that my consent to God opens up a way for that to happen. Mary shows me what is possible when a human being consents to God’s will and renounces their own will and power. She points me to the way to experience the fullness of God in the here and now. Mary challenges me to do the same.
Reckoning with the Toxicity of Christian Nationalism – Wayne Northey
Wayne Northey: The article highlighted below is very disturbing for followers of the one Mark Lewis Taylor dubs The Executed God (book review here, with the subtitle: The Way of the Cross in Lockdown America). I stand in perpetual amazement at how the New Testament...
The “Biblification” of Scripture: Ups & Downs of Canonical Technology – Brad Jersak
The Medium is the Message Marshall McLuhan is most popularly known for the slogan, “The medium is the message,” which was his call to be mindful of the implicit impacts that come with the adoption of any new technology. He suggested four questions (labeled “the tetrad...
Saved from The Wrath (Romans 5:9) – Michael Wood
Saved from The Wrath (Romans 5:9) ‘Much more surely then, now that we have been justified by his blood, will we be saved through him from the wrath of God.’(NRSV) ‘Since we have now been justified by his blood, how much more shall we be saved from God’s wrath through...
“Life in Christ: Ecclesia & Liturgical Function” Interview with David Goa – Brad Jersak
Brad Jersak: In a previous interview over breakfast, you late out a rich and layered definition of ecclesia. Prior to that, the chief critique of my own theology was its rather thin version of what I imagined (or overlooked) as "church." I'd like to...
BEYOND “HOPEFUL UNIVERSALISM” – Bradley Jersak
In recent years, I find myself sitting comfortably with friends who would self-identify as “hopeful universalists.” It’s not a label I am comfortable with, for a number of reasons, though I’m certainly fine with the spirit of their intent. The following clarifies why...
The Vicarious Church – Fr Kenneth Tanner
A set of four tweet-length meditations on the vicarious nature of the church as she is described in Acts 2:42:The Sacraments are where we as the body of Christ continue to give our collective life for the life of the world. By them we die with the human God and...
Augustine, Lewis/Inklings, Myth & Hermes the Trickster – Ron Dart
Q & A with Fr. John Behr – “Who has the Spirit?”
"But this he said concerning the Spirit, which they that believed on him were about to receive; for the Spirit was not yet, because Jesus had not yet been glorified. —John 7:39. "Thus it is written, 'The first man, Adam, became a living being'; the...
“An Apologia of Monasticism in an Age of Human Doings and the Idolatry of Achievements” – By Andrew Klager
I teach a course called ‘The Inner Transformation of a Peacemaker’ in the online Certificate program of the Jim Forest Institute for Religion, Peace and Justice at St. Stephen’s University (jfi.ssu.ca). The foundation of this course is Christian contemplation and...
PSA’s Moral Monster – Brad Jersak with Lazar Puhalo
Abp. Lazar: "I'm afraid that Evangelicalism itself can ultimately lead a thinking person away from Christ altogether. There is absolutely no doubt in my mind that fundamentalism and the right-wing can do this, and most certainly does. When hate is interpreted...
