The Cross: Somber Joy or Blasphemous Spectacle? – David Goa
Take the suffering—all the expressions of the passions in this life—of the world on yourself rather than passing it on. If we don’t take them on ourselves, we react to them and reduce them to reciprocity. We could bring an end to that. Don’t presume about it. Don’t react. Let it be. See as I see. Say what I say. Why have you abandoned me and into thy hands… then don’t make something of it. Bear your cross, don’t make something out of it. Just let it be what it is.
The big issue is what the spiritual landscape when you have a theology of the Cross or a Christus victor theology where you might affirm the doctrine of the Incarnation but in your whole way of understanding formally liturgically and in prayer, if the only thing you have is the Cross and the Incarnation is a set of events that lead to the Cross, descent and resurrection, you reduce the incarnation to the suffering of the world. That’s mischievous. And romanticizes suffering.
In the East, the Incarnation, lent and Pascha highlight that part of the story as part of a season, not the point or even as the culmination. They’re of a piece. Iconic images of human experience and the human journey. Fetishism of pain and sorrow. It makes the Incarnation only the birth and doesn’t link the Logos and the logoi. But it isn’t about God, it’s about the human being. You have these gifts of memory, imagination, the human problem is about being discarnate and not present, only projecting our nostalgia or our utopian dreams. The human problem and how to be incarnate, and human nature. Jesus Christ is two natures. The revelation of God is a midrash of Genesis 3. The image of the fulness of the human nature. Tree of Life.
Gibson’s film was a form of blasphemy that reduces the Logos to suffering and death, cultivating I us aa romantic attachment to that, and we can find who isn’t in Jesus’ camp and do it to them. It mythologizes, not the incarnation, logos or human nature, but of the human passions of the worst order.
Turn a biblical narrative into a spectacle and you will turn it into a blasphemy. That’s the devil. You make it a servant of evil instead of the good. Because it plants the seeds of literalism and historicism that ruins the bloody story. And lose the iconic revelation of our being and becoming. He came to redeem the world, not ‘history’ through our being and becoming. History will only be transfigured through being present to this life. The films can be reductionistic heresy.
Holy week should be the opposite of a performance. We are praying our way into the unfolding of our experience so we pray it, we don’t perform it. The great temptation of Satan is to perform the Good. Then he wins. Because when you perform something, you aren’t present to it. Prayer makes you present to what is real, the movements of the Logos and your logoi in all your experience. They talk to each other there and that’s why they weep. Shouting ‘he is risen’ can make us forget that this is what this is for us. “Holy week is somber joy.” The leper, the woman at the well, Lazarus raising holds together the wonder of our pain and unfolding healing.
The Peace Prayers in Leipzig (1989) – Roger Newell
Photo: Martin Naumann Reflections on the 33rd Anniversary of the Peace Prayers in Leipzig, October 9, 1989 The cold war suddenly and nonviolently ended, and the end of history was proclaimed as the triumph of democracy and freedom. Yet today there is a hot war in...
“Where do you lie on the political spectrum” – Poem by Becky Jaster
“So where do you lie on the political spectrum?” “I’m inclined to rest somewhere beyond it: a birds eye view, in search of truth up a tree, I typically sit… Ironically this feels much more like a place of common ground there’s...
Paul: from Hardline Guardian to Slave of Christ – Fr. Sean Davidson
In first century Judea, most people thought they knew what was needed to make Israel great again: a strong Messiah who would rise up against Israel’s enemies, within and without, and rule the world with peace and justice from Jerusalem. That Jesus initially seemed...
“Tribal Visions Beyond Zionism” – Rabbi Lynn Gottlieb
Invitation from Rabbi Lynn Gottlieb Dear friends, This year I am offering a once a month class called Jewish Tribal Visions Beyond Zionism. First class begins this Thursday at 6 PM PST on zoom. As we prepare for the high holidays, join me in the work...
Healing from and through Deconstruction – Felicia Murrell with Susan Carson
Thursday, October 27, 6:00 pm EST Susan Carson (Roots & Branches network)will host a livestream fundraising event: "Healing From and Through Our Deconstruction"An evening with Dr. Bradley Jersak, Felicia Murrell and Wm. Paul Young" CLICK HERE...
The Wages vs. the Gift – Steve Robinson
"The wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord." Romans 6:23 It's amazing how a "framework" can constrain how we understand a piece of text. For example, 2x4 is either 8 or a piece of lumber...
Under Judgment with Jesus – Fr. Sean Davidson
Something really interesting about discipleship from its inception. Jesus doesn’t allow his followers to think of themselves as revolutionaries. Practically speaking, they are stuck with the consequences of Israel’s failures. This is the context of their life and...
For the Unity of One Church – David Goa, Abp Lazar Puhalo, Dr. Petros Vassiliados
In launching the new book, For the Unity of One Church, David Goa hosts a conversation with the editors, Abp Lazar Puhalo and Dr. Petros Vassiliados. They discuss key issues around church unity, the female diaconate, and the impact of the war in Ukraine. The video...
Interfaith Peacemakers Summit with Safi Kaskas & Friends – by Brad Jersak
“Blessed are the peacemakers. They shall be called children of God.” —Jesus I write this testimony of God’s grace while the events are still fresh in my mind and warm in my heart. For the anniversary of 9-11, I was invited to participate in an international gathering...
Before Tolkien 5: TWILIGHT OF THE GODS – Ron Dart
Ron Dart completes his exegesis of Richard Wagner's "Ring of the Nibelung" with a reflection on the final act, "Twilight of the Gods." Previous in this series: Before Tolkien 1 - Richard Wagner's THE RING OF THE NIBELUNG: Then and Now...
